The Man Who Made A Monster
By J.E SMITH
1
Renee Holt's remains were placed in the ground in the hot Key West dirt. The ocean could be seen in the distance. Blue and bright and beautiful and uncaring.
She was pulled under while diving one afternoon and only half of her made it to the surface. What was found after five days of searching was resting on a coral shelf in about fifteen feet of water.
There was a shadow moving through those waters as well. It crept through the shallows of the Florida Keys in the summer of 2007.
The warm shallows of the Gulf off of Pelican Cay, Florida. A small island home to nine thousand people. Each July twenty-seven thousand more would flock to the island with their children. Life jackets, beach umbrellas, coolers full of soda and rented kayaks. They all believed the water was safe because the county put signs up that said so.
The Gulf of Mexico is warm. It spans over six hundred thousand square miles and can reach depths of twelve thousand feet. There are areas that have not been mapped to this day.
There were deaths in the warm waters off of Pelican Cay between 2008 and 2013. Deaths in the shallows. Forty miles of shoreline all within reach of one marina and three GPS coordinates. These coordinates had been used by a man named Douglas Charles to feed a fish since the spring of 2007.
Megan Daniels was the first to die in the summer of 2008. She was swimming two hundred yards off the public beach when she was pulled under. She was twenty-nine years old with two children and a husband. She loved to work out and was in great shape. She did Ironman’s locally and wanted to compete on Ninja Warrior one day. She was healthy and knew how to swim. She was bitten on her midsection and bled out approximately half a mile from shore. The county ruled it a shark attack which was true. An isolated incident which was not.
Marine biologists came out and determined that the fish was between fifteen and sixteen feet long. A great hammerhead. The biggest of its kind and one of the few species known to attack humans without provocation. They used the term behavioral pattern in their findings. They did not use the word monster.
No one ever caught the thing or got a clear picture of it. All that was left was what it took with it. Pelican Cay was never the same. Just like any small town when they learn that what killed their citizens is still out there.
Roland Paul was next. A college student that went on a charter trip and never made it back. Kellie Burgess in 2010. The doctors at Sacred Heart Medical noted that she had a propeller strike on her right leg. After further testing from the authorities in Tallahassee, they changed the entry.
Randall Hess in 2012. Only part of his body was recovered and the rest was assumed to have been taken by the current. And finally, Renee Holt. A forty-one-year-old woman that was swimming in the water at dusk one October afternoon in 2013. The time of day that the park authority had told people to stay out of the water for the past two years.
The county ruled it a rogue and the park authority updated their signs. The local dive shop Deep Sea Daves lost about ten-thousand dollars. They went seven weekends in a row without renting out paddle boards. The owner told the Pelican Cay Courier that he felt it was unfair to his business.
2
Douglas Charles ran sunset tours out of the Pelican Cay Marina. He had a boat that he converted to a center console and named Meridian Blue. He was forty-four years old and had a big belly. He always wore bright pink shirts with a flamingo on them and gold rimmed glasses. He was balding and wore a Rolex. He looked like he had money. He was from Port Arthur, Texas and used to work in the oil industry. He had been in Pelican Cay for eleven years when they found him.
He was the type of guy that you would see in pictures on boats with people that were having fun. Holding up bottles of champagne and smiling. When you look back on those pictures it doesn't look like they are happy.
The people that worked at the marina said that he was a hard working businessman. He always paid his bills on time and kept his boat in good condition. He would repaint his boat every two years and take care of his engines. He didn't drink at the bar like most charter captains did. He wasn't mean and would tip the waitresses well. He did like to get a little dirty first though. Maybe touch a girl's shoulder or rub her hand. If they played along with him and acted flirty he would tip them more. The people that worked with him for ten years told investigators that he never said anything weird to them.
They found hard drives in his 4,800 square foot mansion in Key West. Palm trees ran along the property, and a twelve-foot iron gate marked with his initials, DC, stood at the entrance. A marine biologist by the name of Kristine Rubio looked over the hard drives. She said that it was the best organized collection of information that she had ever seen on someone training a predator to kill. This wasn't some unhinged person acting on a whim. This man was evil. He knew how to work with people and get them to trust you. Curious about the outcome, he committed six years to it.
Douglas Charles was chumming the waters for six years. Not like every charter captain does and throw some bait over the side of the boat. He was dumping sixty lbs of fish blood and ground up menhaden in the same three GPS coordinates. For six years, he was conditioning a fish to attack people in the water.
Carolyn Frazier was a forensic behavioral analyst that explained this to the grand jury in the spring of 2014. She was thirty-eight years old and studied marine predators and had a second degree in behavioral science. She explained to the jury that what Douglas Charles was doing was creating snuff films. Watching was the only thing he cared about. She called him a sick fuck to his face. She said that he probably enjoyed hearing them scream. She had no proof of that, but she felt that he didn't deserve better. He had a camera with a waterproof housing and eleven hard drives that were found in a storage unit near the marina. There were seventeen encounters that were captured on those hard drives over the course of six years. Every one of them was fatal.
Douglas Charles posted bail for ninety million dollars. He died a few days later on his boat Meridian Blue. He went out to see his pet one last time. Mitch Houston was a Florida marine wildlife officer that was working on the case for 8 months. He found Douglas on the boat and went over to speak with him. The altercation happened in the water. Douglas went in first and started fighting. The fish was there waiting.
Mitch was found on the swim platform of the boat with lacerations on his left shoulder. He also had severe damage to his right knee. Douglas was never found and is presumed dead. The fish was never caught. Its still out there.